The answer to this question is simple enough, If we allow students to research a project that genuinely interests them, they will be much more involved in their education. This is effective because as mentioned in my earlier blog, student directed learning is always a good idea. Of course its not this simple, you can't always trust a student to direct 100% of their learning. If this was the case more than a few projects would have little to no relation to the course content.
![]() |
| No Jimmy, you cant do your project on a tomato |
This is why if a class is implementing Genius Hour it is important that the teacher monitors the learning environment and makes sure that everyone is on task. Students should run their ideas for Genius Hour by the teacher, to make sure that it is appropriate. After students are done researching their project they will be given the opportunity to present their findings to the rest of the class. It is often surprising how ingenious a students ideas are, if they are genuinely interested in their topic. This is exactly what we are trying to achieve through Genius Hour.
This concept was recently implemented in my education class, where we were to get into groups and present our findings on a question relating to education. I would like to take this opportunity to discuss a Genius Hour topic which I found to be interesting. The first topic I would like to discuss was from a group whose topic was: Why physed should be a mandatory class throughout high school. If you don't already know, physed is a mandatory class in grade 9, but optional from there on out, so the point of this presentation is that everyone should have to take it for all four years. Before I begin I want to make it known that I believe physed is a course which is often underestimated for its importance in the education curriculum. Especially in an age where student health is overlooked and obesity is on the rise, our secondary education often focuses solely on the mental abilities of a student, compared to the physical, both of which are important. Now that the cards are on the table, I also should make it known that I don't believe physed should be made fully mandatory. Now there are a couple reasons why this topic and presentation frustrated me.The first reason is something which we should all keep in mind when presenting a topic. This group set up a survey through facebook where they tallied why people did or did not like physed, as well as whether or not they think it should be mandatory or not. I love it. Great idea. Statistics are a great way to make a point and are concrete. But the group also admitted that the people who took this survey were on their friends list, and therefore the majority of which were also involved in a post secondary program related to physed. This means that the results were extremely biased in favour of keeping physed mandatory, where an overwhelming 90% (approximation) of people said physed should be mandatory. The reason I picked this part out of the presentation is partially because the way they went about proving their point isn't accurate, but also partially because I'm a math junkie and seem to have to find a way to relate every blog post to math. Exhibit A:
![]() |
| I have a problem. |
![]() |
How do we fix this? I don't know, I'm just a math teacher. Maybe one day when I have my own classroom I'll devote a single lesson to sexual education, partially because I think its important, but mostly because my students will be so confused and thrown off they will forever revere me for being able to throw a curve ball at them at any time.
The second reason physed is useful is for the fitness aspect. At this time some young adults have been introduced to a life of fitness, those who have already spent years on the ice playing hockey or on the field with a soccer ball. There is also the other half of the population who are similar to me, those who know nothing about fitness, and can't even skate. If given the choice in grade 9, me and my fitness-phobic peers would never take physed, but this is why it is so important that it is so mandatory. Grade 9 physed teaches those who are unaware the importance of a healthy lifestyle. They can use this information to hopefully continue a healthy lifestyle in future years.
Although I find physed irreplaceable, I also find it illogical to have it mandatory for all four years of high school. I believe that physed is just as important as art, history, and many other topics which are not fully mandatory in high school. So why should physed be mandatory if none of these other courses are? I believe that the only fully mandatory course in high school is English, even core subjects such as math or science do not have to be studied throughout all four years. At the end of the day the point of high school is to prepare a student for post secondary education or work. There is often little to no room for students pursuing post secondary education to take an elective that does not relate to their topic of interest. Therefore if physed is fully mandatory, so should a number of other classes. There is simply not enough room in a students schedule to take more than one or two courses which do not directly relate to their preferred field of study. If students want to take physed classes, they have the option of choosing it as their field of study or even making it an elective. Therefore even though I find physed important, I believe that it should only be mandatory in grade 9.
Tadah! We have finally finished my blog section. The end of an era, one might call it. No one calls it that, I'm probably lying to you. Thank you for sticking with me throughout this journey blog friends, you have been great listeners. Stay golden ponyboy <3
Mark




